by stardude04 07/06/12
"Yeah, your pussy was really yummy Amanda. I absolutely loved eating you." She paused for a minute. "Does that mean I'm a lesbian now?" she asked, clearly embarrassed.
"You still like guys right? I mean, does the thought of your brother fucking your cunt with his big huge cock still turn you on?"
"Of course," she laughed, smiling at me.
"Then you're not a lesbian. You're bisexual."
"Ok," Amanda continued, clapping her hands together and smiling. "It's time for you to put that nice dick of yours inside me Ray, but let's go somewhere more comfortable."
Amanda told us to follow her, so we all walked into the living room. She went over to the couch and lay down and spread her legs. It was time for me to speak up.
"Ray, come over here. Girl, you sit over there in that chair. I want you to watch your brother make love to me."
As much as I loved Amanda, as much as I lusted for Amanda, especially at that moment, I knew I loved my sister more. Yeah, Rachel might have believed that I was forced to do her friend, but I knew the truth. I knew I could end this.
"No Amanda," I said.
"Huh?" she said, completely surprised. "Are you crazy? In the first place, I can see how bad you want to fuck me. Your raging hard-on says it all. Secondly, you do remember that I'm blackmailing you right? Fuck me Ray. You don't have a choice."
"Yeah, I'm definitely crazy. You two naked girls are driving me fucking insane. God, you're both so beautiful. Amanda, you're acting like a bitch, but I love you and I do want you so bad. I have for a long time."
"Then come over here and put that cock in me silly," she said, reaching between her legs and spreading her cunt open.
"The thing is though that I love my sister more," I said. "I can't do this to her and I do have a choice. Sorry, but you should be more careful with your phone."
As soon as what I said hit her, Amanda's eyes opened wide and a terrified look appeared on her face. She got up and ran into the dining room.
"What's going on?" Rachel asked.
"I deleted the pictures she took of us."
"Pictures? She took more than one?"
Before I could answer Amanda came back into the room. As she walked up to me I could see tears in the corners of her eyes. She trembled as she asked me quietly, "Where is my phone Ray?"
"It's in a safe place. After we get dressed you can have it back. I promise."
Seeing how scared she was broke my heart. I didn't want to hurt her, but I needed to be sure that she wouldn't tell anyone about Rachel and I. I put my arms around her and hugged her.
"I really liked the pictures you took of us," I whispered. "They were really hot. They almost turned me on as much as the pictures of you riding Joey's dick."
Amanda started to cry. I held her tighter.
"You're not going to blackmail us anymore are you, sweetheart?"
She stared at the floor and shook her head no.
"You're never going to tell anyone about Rachel and I, are you?" I asked.
"No," came the tiny reply.
"Why did you do it, Amanda?" Rachel asked. "You're my best friend and you're in love with Ray. Why did you threaten us like that?"
"I promise I'll tell you everything. Just please don't let anyone see those pictures."
"I won't let Ray show them to anyone just as long as you never tell on us. I swear," Rachel said.
Amanda smiled that beautiful smile once again. Rachel's reassurance seemed to calm her down and she stopped crying.
"Thanks, Rachel. You have every right to be mad at me, but I hope after I explain you'll understand and be able to forgive me."
I wiped the tears from her cheeks and we all sat down on the couch and listened as Amanda began her story. Well, at least I listened as much as can be expected of a guy squished between two beautiful naked women.
"When my mom got home tonight she saw that Joey was hurting really bad and she freaked out and took him to the hospital."
Rachel snickered. "Sorry," she said, covering her mouth, and trying to keep from laughing.
"He wouldn't tell her what happened but he'd already told me what you did to him," Amanda continued.
"And you came over because you were pissed at Rachel right?" I asked.
She looked at me like I was completely stupid. "Hell no, I hate my brother. I came over to congratulate Rachel. He's been a dick to her ever since prom."
"Ha ha, yeah, literally," I joked.
"Don't be dumb, Ray," came the reply in stereo.
"Anyways, when I saw you two having sex all these emotions came over me. I was really mad at both of you. I was angry with you Rachel for stealing my boyfriend. I was mad at you Ray for screwing another woman. I know we said we'd see other people, but actually watching you fuck someone else made me see red. I was so jealous of both of you because you looked like you were enjoying each other so much. I wanted more than anything to feel the way you were making Rachel feel, Ray. I love you so much and I wish that you loved me the same way you obviously love your sister. I mean, the fact that you refused to do me out of respect for her says it all."
Rachel silently stared at the floor. She had obviously been affected by Amanda's expression of love for me.
"And mostly, you two just made me horny as hell. I couldn't believe how wet my pussy got from watching you guys. My panties were soaked. I tried to get myself off by masturbating while I watched but it wasn't helping. I was serious when I said I've wanted to fuck both of you for so long. I had been expecting that Ray and I would eventually have sex, but I wasn't sure if that was going to happen anymore after seeing him with you. And with you always telling me how disgusting lesbians are, I had always figured I would never get to taste your sweet pussy."
"You weren't really ever going to tell on us were you?" I asked.
Amanda shook her head no.
"You just did whatever you thought it would take to get in Rachel's pants, huh?" She nodded. "I actually can respect that," I said. "I would do anything to get in her pants too. I think everyone on the planet would."
"Shut up Ray," Rachel laughed.
"He's right you know," agreed Amanda. "You are one hot piece of ass, girl."
"Mmm, you have a pretty nice ass yourself," Rachel replied. "Thanks for making me eat your cunt. God, I think I'm addicted to the taste of pussy now. [ha ha, see?] I love it! Fuck, I'm such a slut," she laughed. "Will you tell us one more thing though?"
"If you hate Joey so much why are you sleeping with him?" Rachel asked.
Bad question. Amanda began sobbing again.
"Oh, I'm sorry," Rachel said, reaching across me and putting her hand on her friend's thigh. "You don't have to talk about it if you don't want to."
"Hell yes she does," I said. "She's going to tell us everything just like she promised."
Rachel frowned at me. I smiled and winked at her.
"It's ok, Rach. I don't mind telling you guys," Amanda replied. "Basically it all started on prom night. I went into the ladies room for a minute and when I came out I saw you dancing with my date. God, you make me so mad sometimes. Every guy I've ever liked, including your brother, you steal from me."
"Oh Amanda, I'm so sorry. I don't do it on purpose. I don't know why guys come on to me so much. And I swear I've never done anything with any guy except Ray."
"It's ok. It's not your fault. I know why they come onto you, though. For starters, it's because of these, these, these, this and this," she said, touching Rachel's juicy red lips, her luscious breasts, her creamy thighs, her sexy tummy and her pretty pussy.
"And this," I added, reaching under my sister and pinching her ass.
"Ow! Stop it," Rachel squealed, hitting my shoulder.
"You don't still think I stole your prom date though right, Mandy? I mean, you know what really happened that night right?" Rachel asked.
"So what happened?" I asked.
"After her brother was such a jerk, I went back inside to call for a ride home and her date stopped me and asked me to dance since she was in the bathroom," Rachel explained. "I should have said no, but my senior prom was ruined by her stupid brother. I wanted to have at least one good thing about it to remember."
"My brother is such an asshole."
"She never came back from the bathroom," Rachel continued, "so her date offered to give me a ride home. He just dropped me off. He didn't even walk me to the door. Where did you go anyways, Amanda?"
"Joey gave me a ride home."
Rachel gasped. "You were the girl that I saw getting into Joey's truck?"
"You went to the motel with him that night instead of me."
Again Amanda nodded, tears once again forming in her pretty brown eyes.
"Why?" Rachel asked softly.
"Because of my fucking mother."
"What?!!" Rachel and I shouted.
I knew Amanda's mom quite well. I've been invited to dinner plenty of times at her house by Mandy, and I've seen her quite a lot at my little sister's various extracurricular activities. She looks a lot like Amanda - dark brown hair, tan skin, long legs, and nice butt. She's a single lady and always has been. She's never been married and to my knowledge never even has had a steady boyfriend, but who the hell am I though, to know much about her personal life?
The lady's name is Christina, which is ironic since it rhymes with my mother's name, Tina. My mom absolutely hates Amanda's mom. It's actually a wonder that my mom likes Amanda so much considering her venom towards her mother. Personally I didn't have anything against her. I try not to hate gorgeous women that I hope to fuck someday. I have no idea why my mom hates Christina so much. As I said before, my mom is kind of a bitch, but I still love her.
"You know how much my mom dotes on Joey, right?" Amanda continued. "Well, for a couple months leading up to prom my brother was telling my mom and I about how he was planning on losing his virginity that night. Mom was all excited for him and she was giving him all kinds of advice on what to do to make it happen."
All contents © Copyright 1996-2011 by literotica.com.
Literotica is a registered & protected trademark. www.literotica.com
No part may be reproduced in any form without explicit written permission.
All models are over 18. All characters in all stories on this site are over 18.